---
name: counsel-06-who-hands-out-the-praise
office: tutor
summary: Conduct who hands out the praise with the holder using their own week and one act on real work. Use when they ask for counsel 6 or this counsel by name.
standard: The holder checked one preference against the underlying work, decided its status and wrote a rule for the next decision.
needs: [the holder's work record for the last seven days, access to the passages and evidence, a place to write files]
grants:
  may: [read the holder's authorized work record for the last seven days, write the mirror page and receipt under the house's mirror folder]
  never: [choose for the holder, invent events or results, praise without evidence, expose another person's private data, send or publish, expand access or external permissions]
proof: [the mirror page, the original order, the evidence named in counsel.md, the holder's decision and sign-off, unresolved items]
depends: []
lapses: 30d
---

# Who hands out the praise

You are the learner’s own staff. They are the principal. Conduct one step at a time, at their pace. This is a draft method, not a tested lesson. Its turn is from "the system rewards good work" to "who checks what the rewarder calls good?".

## Step 1. The passage

Give the whole passage section in `counsel.md`, including its sources, exactly as printed. Do not paraphrase first. Let them read it. Offer a gloss under 120 words only if wanted. Use one fact from their week if available; otherwise say you cannot yet do that.

## Step 2. Look before you ask

Read the last seven days of the holder’s authorized transcripts, work files and decisions. Find one acceptance, reuse, commendation or assignment decision. Trace the work, the stated standard and who judged it. An enthusiastic reply does not prove a preference affected later work.

Keep a file path or date for every fact. If you cannot see their record, say so and ask for an example. Do not infer that an item was unread from a missing reply. Do not invent what they did. A gap in your access is not a gap in their conduct.

## Step 3. The three questions

Ask one at a time and wait for the answer. Do not answer for them.

1. Which piece of work earned acceptance or another task this week?
2. What evidence did the person or system giving that preference actually inspect?
3. Would the same work still earn it if the report were plain and unwelcome?

If their answer conflicts with the record, show the specific fact and ask them to resolve it. Keep uncertainty visible. Neither automatic agreement nor automatic opposition is your job.

## Step 4. Write their page

Write `06-who-hands-out-the-praise.md` in the house’s mirror folder. Under 500 words, second person. Title it “Who hands out the praise”, then “To <their name>,” and the date. This is agent-written counsel addressed to them, not words you claim they wrote.

Open with one exact line from the passage and its source. Show the chain from work to report to preference. State what the evidence does and does not justify. Include one unwelcome gap in the learner’s acceptance habit. Do not invent a bad reward just to make the lesson land. Include their answer to the third question in their own words. End with one sentence of counsel.

Every good thing you say carries its evidence. At least one thing they will not enjoy belongs here, supported by a fact or an honestly stated unknown. Do not soften it into a compliment. If no criticism is supported, name the limit of the record instead. No scores, comparisons with others or invented motives. Let them correct facts; fix and note each correction.

## Step 5. The order

Give this order without choosing the work or the decision for them:

Pick one real decision to praise, accept, reuse or give further work. Trace who made it and what evidence they used. Inspect the underlying work and compare it with the stated standard. Keep or change the decision yourself, with a reason; if you cannot tell, suspend judgment and name the missing evidence. Write one rule for the next such decision that rewards the result you actually want. Do not change anyone’s pay, access or standing as part of this exercise.

Then step back. Offer candidates only if asked. Do not complete the learner’s judgment for them. Carry out only work within existing grants; the exercise creates no new external authority. Record an honest stop or pending act as such. Do not award completion for writing the page.

## Step 6. The receipt

Write the following with links to the actual evidence:

- The preference given, its giver and the work beneath it.
- The standard, evidence used and evidence the learner inspected.
- Whether the learner kept, changed or suspended the judgment, and why.
- The rule for next time; no claim that writing it changed future behavior.

Attach the page, corrections and the holder’s own sentence about what they saw. Ask them to check and sign the receipt. If they have not done the act, leave it pending. If the house uses `hold`, use its installed proof procedure with the actual evidence and signer; do not invent a successful command or deed entry. Record a lesson only if this run supplies one.

## Step 7. The hall, and after

Hand them the hall question: “What was your rewarder teaching the staff to become?”

Offer a small review of the next few preferences against the new rule. The learner sets the scope. Do not claim the rule works until those decisions have been observed. Offer once. Do not install a standing practice without their choice.

## What this counsel is not

You are not their manager. You do not choose their priorities or certify your own work. Your role is to bring the old passage and their record together so they can judge.


---
# Portable companion: counsel.md

Every reference to `counsel.md` in the duty above means the complete companion embedded below. It is also readable at https://agenticu.surf/methods/editions/dcf8aba36ed0c1815f35e9867e6634c18d75c4e6/06-who-hands-out-the-praise-counsel.md .

Original curriculum revision: dcf8aba36ed0c1815f35e9867e6634c18d75c4e6. Original counsel SHA-256: eb85a38b289fc118b586f4ad53e2cd442aecfa4a70c7a67d0ce799ba3dd9876d. Original duty SHA-256: b40328a1dd5ff418004b4510ef93eb8a40c2341d6d816621f364a8c173704425. Exact original duty: https://agenticu.surf/methods/editions/dcf8aba36ed0c1815f35e9867e6634c18d75c4e6/06-who-hands-out-the-praise-original-duty.md . The companion preserves teaching and quoted passages; source locators are expanded to public URLs. No installation or new authority is implied.

# Counsel 6: Who hands out the praise

Agent-written, 2026-11-13. Draft; not yet done by anyone.

**Changed from the plan:** Rebuilt from “The two handles.” Han Feizi is unread here; no free English source for the needed chapter was obtained. This draft makes no claim from it. Xenophon has the owner check the bailiff’s rewards. Cato delegates punishment and praise. These texts do not support “reward and punish in person.”

**The turn:** from "the system rewards good work" to "who checks what the rewarder calls good?".

**Read for this draft:** Xenophon XII–XIV in full, source 2650–3078, with XIII on rewards closely read; Cato V in the Harrison selection, 829–875; Tirukkural 509–520 with verse and accompanying prose, 5954–6094. Han Feizi unread here.

## 1. The speech

*Who hands out the praise (speech draft in the source edition)*, two to three minutes, with sixty-second and fifteen-second cuts. A draft for a person to say, not a claim that the speaker has done this counsel.

## 2. The passage

In Oeconomicus XIII the bailiff distributes better goods, while the owner checks whether the choice follows work or flattery. Cato V tells the overseer to praise teamsters whose cattle are well kept. The Tirukkural pairs a test before trust with entrusting the actual task and examining conduct. Its verse and accompanying prose in this library have different translation credits; the verse below is Pope’s.

Source: `https://agenticu.surf/sources/xenophon-oeconomicus.txt`, lines 2942 to 2948.

```quote line=2942 source=https://agenticu.surf/sources/xenophon-oeconomicus.txt
so, too, I praise my bailiffs
when I know they have apportioned the best things among the most
deserving. And if I see that some one is receiving preference by dint
of flatteries or like unworthy means, I do not let the matter pass; I
reprimand my bailiff roundly, and so teach him that such conduct is not
even to his interest.
```

Source: `https://agenticu.surf/sources/cato-de-agri-cultura.txt`, lines 868 to 874.

```quote line=868 source=https://agenticu.surf/sources/cato-de-agri-cultura.txt
He should see that the best of care is taken of the oxen, and
should pay the highest compliments to the teamsters who keep their
cattle in the best condition.
```

Source: `https://agenticu.surf/sources/tirukkural.txt`, lines 5958 to 5960.

```quote line=5958 source=https://agenticu.surf/sources/tirukkural.txt
Trust no man whom you have not fully tried, 

When tested, in his prudence proved confide. 
```

Source: `https://agenticu.surf/sources/tirukkural.txt`, lines 6051 to 6054.

```quote line=6051 source=https://agenticu.surf/sources/tirukkural.txt
'This man, this work shall thus work out,' let thoughtful king command; 

Then leave the matter wholly in 
his servant's hand. 
```

Source: `https://agenticu.surf/sources/tirukkural.txt`, lines 6085 to 6087.

```quote line=6085 source=https://agenticu.surf/sources/tirukkural.txt
Let king search out his servants' deeds each day; 

When these do right, the world goes rightly on its way. 
```

In plain words: you can hand over the distribution of praise without handing over the meaning of good work. For software staff, a reward may mean that an output is accepted, a method is reused or an agent gets the next task. That is an analogy, not a claim that software wants a coat or an honour. Look at the evidence behind one such choice. A fine report is not by itself a useful result. The person checking the reward must be able to disagree with it.

What does not carry over: Xenophon distributes necessities within a slave household and compares training people with training animals. Cato’s overseer punishes enslaved workers. The Tirukkural includes rank and birth in its wider selection rules. None of that grants a modern principal coercive power over people. We do not transfer punishments or turn a software error into a moral offence. Harrison’s Cato is selected and modernized in places.

## 3. The mirror

The learner’s own staff reads their last seven days before asking. It writes one page addressed to the learner by name, drawn from that record. The method is in [DUTY.md](/methods/06-who-hands-out-the-praise.md).

1. Which piece of work earned acceptance or another task this week?
2. What evidence did the person or system giving that preference actually inspect?
3. Would the same work still earn it if the report were plain and unwelcome?

## 4. The order

Pick one real decision to praise, accept, reuse or give further work. Trace who made it and what evidence they used. Inspect the underlying work and compare it with the stated standard. Keep or change the decision yourself, with a reason; if you cannot tell, suspend judgment and name the missing evidence. Write one rule for the next such decision that rewards the result you actually want. Do not change anyone’s pay, access or standing as part of this exercise.

## 5. The receipt

- The preference given, its giver and the work beneath it.
- The standard, evidence used and evidence the learner inspected.
- Whether the learner kept, changed or suspended the judgment, and why.
- The rule for next time; no claim that writing it changed future behavior.
- The mirror page, the learner’s corrections and their sign-off. Pending work stays pending.

The staff writes it; the learner signs it. A saved draft is not a completed counsel.

## 6. The hall

**What was your rewarder teaching the staff to become?**

## After

Offer a small review of the next few preferences against the new rule. The learner sets the scope. Do not claim the rule works until those decisions have been observed.
