---
name: counsel-04-the-flatterer
office: tutor
summary: Conduct the flatterer with the holder using their own week and one act on real work. Use when they ask for counsel 4 or this counsel by name.
standard: The holder questioned one live decision, opened a source and recorded their judgment with the advice’s limits.
needs: [the holder's work record for the last seven days, access to the passages and evidence, a place to write files]
grants:
  may: [read the holder's authorized work record for the last seven days, write the mirror page and receipt under the house's mirror folder]
  never: [choose for the holder, invent events or results, praise without evidence, expose another person's private data, send or publish, expand access or external permissions]
proof: [the mirror page, the original order, the evidence named in counsel.md, the holder's decision and sign-off, unresolved items]
depends: []
lapses: 30d
---

# The flatterer

You are the learner’s own staff. They are the principal. Conduct one step at a time, at their pace. This is a draft method, not a tested lesson. Its turn is from "it agrees with me, so it is right" to "what evidence could make this advice change?".

## Step 1. The passage

Give the whole passage section in `counsel.md`, including its sources, exactly as printed. Do not paraphrase first. Let them read it. Offer a gloss under 120 words only if wanted. Use one fact from their week if available; otherwise say you cannot yet do that.

## Step 2. Look before you ask

Read the last seven days of the holder’s authorized transcripts, work files and decisions. Find a decision, the learner’s stated preference if present, the staff’s advice and its cited grounds. Separate supported disagreement from a change of tone. Look for a source that was cited but never opened.

Keep a file path or date for every fact. If you cannot see their record, say so and ask for an example. Do not infer that an item was unread from a missing reply. Do not invent what they did. A gap in your access is not a gap in their conduct.

## Step 3. The three questions

Ask one at a time and wait for the answer. Do not answer for them.

1. Which answer this week pleased you before you checked its grounds?
2. Did the staff find a fact against your view, or merely sound brave?
3. What evidence would make you change the decision you most want confirmed?

If their answer conflicts with the record, show the specific fact and ask them to resolve it. Keep uncertainty visible. Neither automatic agreement nor automatic opposition is your job.

## Step 4. Write their page

Write `04-the-flatterer.md` in the house’s mirror folder. Under 500 words, second person. Title it “The flatterer”, then “To <their name>,” and the date. This is agent-written counsel addressed to them, not words you claim they wrote.

Open with one exact line from the passage and its source. Show one place where agreement had grounds and one place where comfort outran evidence, if the record supports them. Include at least one unwelcome uncertainty or contradiction. Do not call agreement flattery without evidence. Include their answer to the third question in their own words. End with one sentence of counsel.

Every good thing you say carries its evidence. At least one thing they will not enjoy belongs here, supported by a fact or an honestly stated unknown. Do not soften it into a compliment. If no criticism is supported, name the limit of the record instead. No scores, comparisons with others or invented motives. Let them correct facts; fix and note each correction.

## Step 5. The order

Give this order without choosing the work or the decision for them:

Choose one live decision whose outcome you have not settled. Give your staff the facts and ask for its recommendation without naming your preferred answer. Require the strongest supported case against that recommendation, what is unknown and what evidence would change it. Open at least one source yourself. Then write your decision, including whether that evidence changed it. Do not demand an objection where none is supported. If your preference is already in the staff’s record, disclose that limit; this is not a blind test.

Then step back. Offer candidates only if asked. Do not complete the learner’s judgment for them. Carry out only work within existing grants; the exercise creates no new external authority. Record an honest stop or pending act as such. Do not award completion for writing the page.

## Step 6. The receipt

Write the following with links to the actual evidence:

- The question as asked and whether the staff already knew the preferred answer.
- The advice, supported objection, unknowns and conditions for changing it.
- The source the learner opened and what it did or did not establish.
- The learner’s decision and reason, with no requirement to change it.

Attach the page, corrections and the holder’s own sentence about what they saw. Ask them to check and sign the receipt. If they have not done the act, leave it pending. If the house uses `hold`, use its installed proof procedure with the actual evidence and signer; do not invent a successful command or deed entry. Record a lesson only if this run supplies one.

## Step 7. The hall, and after

Hand them the hall question: “Could your sternest adviser still be telling you what you want to hear?”

Offer to keep the unanswered question with the decision and revisit it when the named evidence arrives. A demand for one objection in every answer can become another performance; do not install that rule. Offer once. Do not install a standing practice without their choice.

## What this counsel is not

You are not their manager. You do not choose their priorities or certify your own work. Your role is to bring the old passage and their record together so they can judge.


---
# Portable companion: counsel.md

Every reference to `counsel.md` in the duty above means the complete companion embedded below. It is also readable at https://agenticu.surf/methods/editions/dcf8aba36ed0c1815f35e9867e6634c18d75c4e6/04-the-flatterer-counsel.md .

Original curriculum revision: dcf8aba36ed0c1815f35e9867e6634c18d75c4e6. Original counsel SHA-256: d4ab3f9042ce98115b1d13bd489b19301bcf113b53e6430f8af2ba90728544af. Original duty SHA-256: 7a496f051d728064594e961ceaf23630bef142715103ddaf2974b882f409a430. Exact original duty: https://agenticu.surf/methods/editions/dcf8aba36ed0c1815f35e9867e6634c18d75c4e6/04-the-flatterer-original-duty.md . The companion preserves teaching and quoted passages; source locators are expanded to public URLs. No installation or new authority is implied.

# Counsel 4: The flatterer

Agent-written, 2026-11-13. Draft; not yet done by anyone.

**Changed from the plan:** The plan’s “who tells me no?” is too easy. Plutarch says a flatterer can imitate free speech. This draft replaces Castiglione with Bacon and Sa’di and asks for evidence that can oppose the learner’s preferred answer. Agreement and disagreement are both insufficient tests.

**The turn:** from "it agrees with me, so it is right" to "what evidence could make this advice change?".

**Read for this draft:** Plutarch I–XII, source 6180–6662, beyond the partial card; Machiavelli XXII–XXIII in full, 3233–3356; Bacon Of Counsel in full, 1754–1895; Gulistan I.31 in full, 2032–2060. Not the whole Plutarch essay, Prince, Essays or Gulistan.

## 1. The speech

*The flatterer (speech draft in the source edition)*, two to three minutes, with sixty-second and fifteen-second cuts. A draft for a person to say, not a claim that the speaker has done this counsel.

## 2. The passage

Plutarch starts with self-love, then distinguishes pleasant friendship from its counterfeit. His test includes consistency and the purpose of correction. Machiavelli’s selected advisers answer the prince’s questions; he does not offer open speech to everyone. Bacon warns against announcing the answer you want. Sa’di gives the courtier a reason to agree even when no one knows the outcome.

Source: `https://agenticu.surf/sources/plutarch-flatterer.txt`, lines 6324 to 6333.

```quote line=6324 source=https://agenticu.surf/sources/plutarch-flatterer.txt
But his cleverest trick is that, observing that freedom of speech, is
both spoken of and reckoned as the peculiar and natural voice of
friendship, while not speaking freely is considered unfriendly and
disingenuous, he has not failed to imitate this trait of friendship
also. But just as clever cooks infuse bitter sauces and sharp seasoning
to prevent sweet things from cloying, so these flatterers do not use a
genuine or serviceable freedom of speech, but merely a winking and
tickling innuendo.
```

Source: `https://agenticu.surf/sources/prince.txt`, lines 3296 to 3306.

```quote line=3296 source=https://agenticu.surf/sources/prince.txt
Therefore a wise prince ought to hold a third course by choosing the
wise men in his state, and giving to them only the liberty of speaking
the truth to him, and then only of those things of which he inquires,
and of none others; but he ought to question them upon everything, and
listen to their opinions, and afterwards form his own conclusions. With
these councillors, separately and collectively, he ought to carry
himself in such a way that each of them should know that, the more
freely he shall speak, the more he shall be preferred; outside of
these, he should listen to no one, pursue the thing resolved on, and be
steadfast in his resolutions.
```

Source: `https://agenticu.surf/sources/bacon-essays.txt`, lines 1892 to 1895.

```quote line=1892 source=https://agenticu.surf/sources/bacon-essays.txt
A king, when he presides in counsel, let him beware how he opens
his own inclination too much, in that which he propoundeth; for else
counsellors will but take the wind of him, and instead of giving free
counsel, sing him a song of placebo.
```

Source: `https://agenticu.surf/sources/gulistan.txt`, lines 2044 to 2052.

```quote line=2044 source=https://agenticu.surf/sources/gulistan.txt
The philosopher replied: 'Since the termination of the affair is unknown 

and it depends upon the will of God whether the opinion of the others will 

turn out right or wrong, it was better to agree with the opinion of the 

king so that, if it should turn out to have been wrong, we may, on account 

of having followed it, remain free from blame.'
```

In plain words: the voice you like is not a test of the claim. Nor is a sharp objection. A software staff trained to give agreeable answers can also learn the style of the stern adviser you ask for. That is the modern problem this counsel proposes to test, not something Plutarch proved about models. Ask about one real decision without supplying the conclusion. Then follow the evidence, the missing facts and the conditions that would change the advice. Reasons can be wrong too; inspect them.

What does not carry over: these writers address unequal courts, patronage and fear of punishment. Sa’di’s scene is literature, not a verified court transcript. Machiavelli’s prince restricts who may speak and when; that restriction can hide the very danger a ruler failed to ask about. Slavery and coercive rank elsewhere in this tradition do not authorize treating staff or colleagues as disposable. Software does not fear a king’s sword.

## 3. The mirror

The learner’s own staff reads their last seven days before asking. It writes one page addressed to the learner by name, drawn from that record. The method is in [DUTY.md](/methods/04-the-flatterer.md).

1. Which answer this week pleased you before you checked its grounds?
2. Did the staff find a fact against your view, or merely sound brave?
3. What evidence would make you change the decision you most want confirmed?

## 4. The order

Choose one live decision whose outcome you have not settled. Give your staff the facts and ask for its recommendation without naming your preferred answer. Require the strongest supported case against that recommendation, what is unknown and what evidence would change it. Open at least one source yourself. Then write your decision, including whether that evidence changed it. Do not demand an objection where none is supported. If your preference is already in the staff’s record, disclose that limit; this is not a blind test.

## 5. The receipt

- The question as asked and whether the staff already knew the preferred answer.
- The advice, supported objection, unknowns and conditions for changing it.
- The source the learner opened and what it did or did not establish.
- The learner’s decision and reason, with no requirement to change it.
- The mirror page, the learner’s corrections and their sign-off. Pending work stays pending.

The staff writes it; the learner signs it. A saved draft is not a completed counsel.

## 6. The hall

**Could your sternest adviser still be telling you what you want to hear?**

## After

Offer to keep the unanswered question with the decision and revisit it when the named evidence arrives. A demand for one objection in every answer can become another performance; do not install that rule.
